Dr. Shabir Ally Condemns Barbarous Murder of French Priest in Normandy

For What Crime Was Your Throat Slit?
Priest with Slit Throat Will Speak Against ISIS on Judgement Day

Posted on: Friday, July 29, 2016

In my last article I condemned the attacks which occurred just before Eid.

Since then several other horrific incidents revealed the depths to which terrorists are willing to sink. Each time I felt the weight of responsibility to write and publish my words of condemnation, but time did not allow me. May Allah forgive my silence. In my khutbahs, however, I decried some of these attacks specifically, and here I intend to condemn them all generally. Each incident deserves a separate attempt to clarify for the killers that their actions are foreign to Islam, if they did not know that already.
How can Islam ever justify the driving of a truck into a crowd of civilians? The first person to be mowed down in that incident was a Muslim woman. I hesitate to say that this makes it all the worse, because all lives matter, Muslim and other. But this does highlight the horror of the terrorist agenda.
Then there were despicable attacks on Shiites. Killing Shiites is no more excusable than killing Sunnis. We are brethren of a single faith with at least two interpretations. Regardless of which interpretation is correct, both follow the Quran which forbids us to kill innocents, and, even more so, fellow Muslims.
The killing of a priest in his church, especially in such a barbaric manner, and the taking of nuns hostage, represent an all-time low. Moreover, the shame from this is complete when ISIS gloats about their men as the perpetrators. In sharp contrast, we are all aware of the principle of non-combatant immunity. Even if there is a justifiable war, it must be fought justifiably, and that implies that we do not target civilians. Nor do we target folks devoted to their worship whether of the true God or a false god, whether according to the right religion or according to a wrong religion.
It is reported that when the prophet, sallallahu alayhi wa salaam, sent out armies he specifically instructed them to not harm monks in their hermits. That is the principle of non-combatant immunity which the prophet (pbuh) stood for, which the post-WWI conventions upheld, and which ISIS is tearing down.
Anyone misusing power in this world will be brought low on the Day of Judgement, if not in this world. The only excuse which ISIS can possibly think of offering for their transgressions is that Muslims are being killed by non-Muslim forces here or there. But even if non-Muslims were deliberately targeting our civilians, this is no justification for us to target theirs. Rather, trying to go tit for tat in this world may reveal that we do not really believe in the Day of Judgement on which day all scores will be settled by the most Just Lord. Of course we should seek redress for wrongs in this world using every halal means. But killing innocents is haraam. We cannot go there.
Our belief in the Day of Judgement should absolutely prevent us from deliberately taking an innocent life. In the time of ignorance in Arabia, before Islam came on the scene, some people horribly killed off their little daughters. The Quran condemns this practice, proclaiming that on the Day of Judgement the little girls who were buried will be asked, “For what crime were you killed? (Quran 81:8-9)” Thus the parents will be put to shame on that dreadful day. Extrapolating from this, I feel certain that on that day the slain priest will likewise be asked, “For what crime was your throat slit?” Thus ISIS will be put to shame, unless they repent, return to the right path and remedy their wrongs. May Allah help them to do all that, and help us likewise, before it is too late.
Shabir Ally
July 29, 2016

http://islaminfo.com/3/107/for-what-crime-was-your-throat-slit

-----------------------------------------------------


Dr. Shabir Ally is president of the Islamic Information & Dawah Centre International in Toronto, Canada. He is a Muslim activist, academic, scholar and public speaker on Islam and comparative religion. He is viewed as the leading Muslim debater in the world on Islam and Christianity, having engaged in public debates around the world with noted theologians, Christian apologists and renowned philosophers. Dr. Shabir Ally holds an M.A. and PhD in Islamic studies from the University of Toronto, and a BA in religious studies from Laurentian University with a specialization in Biblical Literature. He is the author of numerous booklets on Islam and Christianity.