Problems Arising from Weak or False Hadiths | Dr. Shabir Ally

In this video, learn about the impact of forged or weak hadiths. Dr. Shabir Ally explains that many of the controversies about Islam that arise today stem from these hadiths. He offers an example of hadiths which are graded authentic but contradict each other on basic #Islamic practices. He also offers an example of a hadith which is graded authentic but seems to contradict the #Quran. Host Dr. Safiyyah Ally asks Dr. Shabir Ally why scholars didn’t realize these hadiths were problematic, and how to avoid falling into the trap of judging hadiths based on our whims and desires.

This video is part 3 of our series, CAN WE TRUST #HADITH?

Watch our earlier videos in this series:

Part 1: The Anatomy of Hadith: https://youtu.be/hzs3JEuIgPg

Part 2: The Rise of Hadith Forgery: https://youtu.be/7RnJ0iZZVYw

Coming up soon! Orientalist and academic critiques of the hadith sciences.


0:00 Some forged or weak hadiths seem harmless

0:42 How scholars have graded hadiths
3:38 Many controversies relating to Islam stem from weak or forged hadiths
5:10 Some hadiths which are graded authentic contradict each other
8:33 Some hadiths which are graded authentic seem to contradict the Quran
10:05 Scholars know that hadith by their very nature are uncertain
13:42 Why scholars didn’t realize these hadiths were problematic

14:51 How to tell if we’re judging hadiths based on our whims and desires

► DONATE: http://www.quranspeaks.com/
► SUBSCRIBE: https://www.youtube.com/subscription_center?add_user=quranspeaks

COMMENT, LIKE and SHARE

Facebook: http://www.Facebook.com/LetTheQuranSpeak
Instagram: http://www.Instagram.com/QuranSpeaks.tv
Twitter: http://www.Twitter.com/Quran_Speaks